The Collector’s Guide to Tecmo Bowl

September 5, 2012 at 9:33 pm | Posted in Features | 10 Comments
Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Tecmo’s football franchise is a true flagship in the world of retro sports gaming.  Fueled by 8-bit success on the NES with the still very popular Tecmo Bowl and Tecmo Super Bowl, Tecmo expanded to the 16-bit era before one last hurrah on the PlayStation in 1996.  Spanning just seven years, the series that mastered two-button football gaming retired as sports gaming moved to 3D.  As with many vintage video games, there have been attempted reboots of Tecmo Bowl to stoke the nostalgic fire of gamers.  All told, if you are a fan of the series or looking to experience it for the first time, the Tecmo Bowl library is very manageable from a collecting standpoint. The big question as always is, what are these retro titles worth?  The Collector’s Guide to Tecmo Bowl sets out to cover the entire Tecmo Bowl cannon, from the late 1980s through the re-releases of late.

A couple of quick caveats before we begin.  First, this is a complete guide to the US domestic releases in the series.  The pricing for Famicom, Super Famicom and Mega Drive variants is not included.  Sometimes you can find these on eBay but there was not a large enough sample size to confidently report them.  I regularly use VGPC as a starting point for market gauging but remember that they combine all sales into one number, not taking into account completeness or condition.  I sought out that specific information for the below myself.  The prices stated are for a loose or cart-only copy, followed by the price for a used (but in good condition) complete version.  Where applicable, a price for a new copy is noted.  These are rounded as your mileage will vary depending on where you find the games and of course on eBay you always have to take into account the shipping and handling on a nice sale ($1.00(!)… but + $4.00 to ship).   With that said, in chronological order, here is The Collector’s Guide to Tecmo Bowl.

Tecmo Bowl

Nintendo Entertainment System (February, 1989) – $5 – $10

The original Tecmo Bowl had two print runs, one with Eric Dickerson on Indianapolis, and one with Albert Bentley at running back instead.  Both have the same value.  Despite being the oldest game in the collection, Tecmo Bowl is very common and cart-only copies can typically be found for less than $5.  Oh and if you want a VGA 90 graded brand new copy, you can find it for $4,999.99 on the internet.

Tecmo Bowl

Game Boy (October, 1991) – $3 – $10 – $15

Sculptured Software’s port of Tecmo Bowl to the Game Boy is really good, despite only being in monochrome.  Finding the original box for Game Boy games can be challenging so I included a more common third category here: game + manual ($10).  This is the only portable release of the original NFLPA-licensed Tecmo games.

Tecmo Super Bowl

Nintendo Entertainment System (December, 1991) – $10 – $18

Tecmo Super Bowl is not just one of the best sports titles on the NES, it is also one of the most valuable.   Tecmo Super Bowl is also arguably the most popular sports game on the system as it is still played today, either with the classic rosters from 1991 or the many variations created by enthusiasts for the game.  Even with an ample supply being bought and sold on eBay (especially when demand picks up during football season), the cart still fetches $10 or so, with completed versions ranging closer to $20.

Tecmo Super Bowl

Sega Genesis (January, 1993) – $2 – $5
Super Nintendo (November, 1993) – $5 – $10

Tecmo’s first foray into the 16-bit era starts with what will be a common theme.  The Genesis versions are less rare, less costly and released considerably earlier than their SNES counterparts.  Tecmo Super Bowl for the Genesis and SNES is a port of the NES engine and is the most common game overall in the library with even complete copies being very inexpensive.

Tecmo Super Bowl II: Special Edition

Sega Genesis (January, 1994) – $10 – $20
Super Nintendo (January, 1995) – $25 – $40+

With a tagline of Special Edition, Tecmo Super Bowl II lives up to its title as it is the rarest and move valuable game in the series.  What’s so special about it?  There is the debut of a new Tecmo Bowl engine and a graphical style that features a very 1990s asthetic.  The game also saw a limited release, especially on the SNES side.  Coming out a year later than it’s Sega counterpart, cart-only copies easily get $25 – $30 and finding a complete version is very rare.  The Genesis game holds value also as complete-in-box entries trend towards $20 and above.

Tecmo Super Bowl III: Final Edition

Sega Genesis (August, 1995) – $5 – $10
Super Nintendo (October, 1995) – $10 – $25

Final Edition advanced the familiar Tecmo Bowl style by adding more simulation elements like create-a-player, trading and free agency.  The game also finally launched before the NFL season instead of mid-winter.  This last 16-bit offering falls in-between the other two games in regards to value and scarcity.

Tecmo Super Bowl

Sony PlayStation (August, 1996) – $8 – $20

The last of the official games with a NFL and NFL Player’s Association license, Tecmo Super Bowl for the PlayStation is considered the black sheep of the Tecmo Bowl family.  Different camera angles and a move to PlayStation graphics (semi-early release in the system’s life also) hinder its popularity, however, the game is very customizable and has a season mode that can literally be endless.  Complete copies in good shape go for around $20.

Tecmo Classic Arcade

Xbox (September, 2005) – $5 – $10 (New)

The original Tecmo Bowl arcade game from 1988 is the headliner for this Xbox-only compilation of Tecmo arcade games.  While its value (due to a lack of titles ) is iffy at the full MSRP price ($30.00), the set is very affordable now, including new copies floating around for $10.  While the arcade version of Tecmo Bowl is nothing like the console versions, it is still a must-have for Tecmo enthusiasts.

Tecmo Bowl: Kickoff

Nintendo DS (November, 2008) – $4 – $8 (New)

The first new Tecmo Bowl title in 12 years, Tecmo Bowl: Kickoff works around the lack of a NFL license by making the teams and players completely customizable.  While the playbooks and game options are the same as the original Tecmo Super Bowl, the tiny sprites and graphics are a little lacking.  Still, if you need a portable Tecmo Bowl fix, the game is very inexpensive with new copies available for less than $10.

Tecmo Bowl

Wii Virtual Console (March, 2007) – $5

There’s more than meets the eye when looking at the Virtual Console release of Tecmo Bowl.  Many outlets reported this was a port of the 1989 NES game but this is, in fact, a port of the 1990 Famicom version of Tecmo Bowl.  Tecmo Bowl for the Famicom featured slightly updated rosters (including John Taylor on the 49ers) from the NES version although the teams were the same.  With the NFL Player’s license long expired, the Virtual Console game uses player numbers instead of names.

Tecmo Bowl Throwback

XBox Live Arcade (April, 2010) – $10
PlayStation Network (June, 2010) – $10
iOS (May, 2011) – $8

Tecmo Bowl Throwback was an homage to the Tecmo Bowl days of yore for many gamers.  Reaching an expanded audience for the first time in 15 years,  again you had to make do without a NFL license but the game could be edited and was essentially Tecmo Super Bowl on the NES with a makeover.  The real pluses here were online multiplayer and the ability to switch from HD graphics (which were blocky and porous) to what looked like an 8-bit/16-bit hybrid of the NES/SNES games.  Throwback was also released on iOS devices but the price is not very attractive.

Advertisements

10 Comments »

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

  1. I think there is a misprint. Considering that Tecmo Bowl for the Playstation is worthless, it should probably be $0-$1. 😉

    • 😉 Believe it or not, there seems to be some demand for it.

  2. […] from a collecting standpoint. The big question as always is, what are these retro titles worth?  The Collector’s Guide to Tecmo Bowl sets out to cover the entire Tecmo Bowl cannon, from the late 1980s through the re-releases of […]

  3. Nice read. I wasn’t even aware of so many titles. Outside of the original NES Tecmo Bowl, I don’t have any desire to own any of these other games.

    • The NES games are so popular (and rightfully so), the rest of titles are often overlooked. This is especially true with the rise of Madden and Joe Montana Football on the Genesis (SNES had the Madden series also). The competition on the NES palls in comparison to what Tecmo faced in the 16-bit era.

    • You should get Tecmo Super Bowl, at least.

  4. Great article! If you can get one Tecmo Super Bowl is the one to have!

    • And if you’re limited to just 16-bit, I really like Tecmo Super Bowl for the Genesis (and SNES of course). It’s a port of the NES game just with updated rosters, and game customization like weather, quarter length, and playbook.

      Thanks for posting!

  5. Two items that I didn’t include, but should mention, are the Tiger LCD games. They made both a Tecmo Bowl and Tecmo Super Bowl handheld game. They show up somewhat frequently on eBay.

  6. […] The Collector’s Guide to Tecmo Bowl Tecmo Bowl in Monochrome Retro Replay Diary: Tecmo Bowl The Ten Most Valuable NES Sports Games Share this:EmailPrintTwitterFacebookRedditStumbleUponPinterestDiggTumblrLinkedInLike this:LikeBe the first to like this. […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.
Entries and comments feeds.

%d bloggers like this: